Sermon preached by the Reverend John E. Kitagawa at the Celebration of the Holy Eucharist on Sunday, 13 April 2008 (The Fourth Sunday of Easter), at St. Philip’s In The Hills Parish, Tucson, Arizona

 

TO HAVE LIFE ABUNDANTLY

Acts 2: 42-47; I Peter 2: 19-25; John 10: 1-10

 

   Today's Gospel relies on one of the most enduring images of God's relationship with God's people; and, for God's love for God's people—the shepherd.  The Bible is replete with such imagery.  A good example is in the Book of Ezekiel.  Sheep and shepherd are used to communicate his prophetic message.  Listen to two verses:

 

Ah, you shepherds of Israel who have been feeding yourselves!  Should not shepherds feed the sheep?  You eat the fat, you clothe yourselves with the wool, you slaughter the fatlings; but you do not feed the sheep.  You have not strengthened the weak, you have not healed the sick, you have not bound up the injured, you have not brought back the strayed, you have not sought the lost, but with force and harshness you have ruled them (Ezekiel 34: 2-4).

 

In other words, these "shepherds of Israel" were in deep trouble with God because they were not good or just stewards of God's creation, nor of the covenant with God.  God condemned the wickedness of the shepherds, and promised:

 

"I myself will be the shepherd of my sheep, and I will make them lie down, says the Lord God.  I will seek the lost, and I will bring back the strayed, and I will bind up the injured, and I will strengthen the weak, but the fat and the strong I will destroy" (Ezekiel 34: 15 - 16).

 

   In Ezekiel, God speaks of being the shepherd in the future—“I will ...".  In verses following today's Gospel, Jesus says, "I am the Good Shepherd" (John 10: 11a).  Jesus made this claim because he "lays down his life for the sheep" (John 10: 11b).  This is in sharp contrast to Ezekiel’s "shepherds of Israel," and the cowardice of the "hired hand [who] sees the wolf coming and leaves the sheep and runs away ..." (John 10: 12).

 

   In today's Gospel, Jesus identifies himself as "the gate" (John 10: 7) to the sheepfold.  To fully appreciate the rich meaning of this metaphor, we must understand that the sheepfold was an area, often the yard in front of a house, protected by fences or natural barriers,.  To protect his flock from predators, a shepherd would herd his flock there for the night.  There was no gate to complete the enclosure.  The only way into this protected area was through an opening.  The shepherd would sleep with “his rod and his staff[1]” (Psalm 23: 4) in the opening to the sheepfold, effectively becoming the gate. 

 

   As I reflected on the image of Jesus as gate, I found myself obsessing about a fable hidden deep in the recesses of my memory.  I was remembering a person who had to choose between two doors, and that a hungry tiger was behind one of them.  Having only fairly recently joined the 21st century, it took me a while to think about googling the story.   I found two interesting and relevant references.  The first was a posting entitled Doors:

 

Here's an entirely hypothetical scenario.  You're in a room with two exits, Door A and Door B. By each is a guardian. You need to go through one of the doors.

Door A is light and flimsy, easy to open—just turn the knob and you're through. Reasonably enough, before charging through, you ask Guardian A what's on the other side.  "Joy and delight, an eternal life of perfect happiness, an end to doors and constant traveling…and all you have to do is turn that knob, and believe."  That sounds too good to be true, so you ask how he knows, and whether he has been through the door.  "No, not yet.  But I dream of it every night, and I can also tell you that almost everyone has gone through Door A."  You turn to Guardian B and ask if that's true.  “Yes," he says, "most people do go through Door A. I don't know if it's true about what's on the other side, though."

Door B is rather imposing: it's a huge steel block, bristling with locks and complicated gadgets. It looks like it's going to take time, cleverness and strength to get it open. It's so intimidating, you're not even sure that you'll be able to figure out how to open it. You ask Guardian B if it's as difficult as it looks. "Oh, man, yes…it's hard. At least it was when I was your age—now I've had so much practice at it that I can go through this door easily, all the time. I can't just open it for you, though. I can give you suggestions and hints, but you really do have to do all the work. It's a kind of an admissions test to see if you'll be able to cope on the other side."  This is not entirely encouraging, and you hope there's something as good as joy and delight beyond the door, so you ask what's over there.  "Knowledge," says Guardian B. "Hard work. Interesting ideas. And doors—many more doors, each one harder than the next, and no end to them in sight. Clever people, all working together to open more doors. It's a whole world, a good but complicated place."

Guardian A screams, "HE LIES! There's a tiger on the other side that will kill and eat you. I think it's on fire, too. And worst of all, if you go through Door B, you'll never get to experience the beautiful life behind Door A. Guardian B is evil, and he wants you to suffer!"  Guardian B just rolls his eyes. He's heard this before.  "Look, kid, Guardian A means well, but he doesn't know anything. I've told you the truth about what's behind my door; maybe “A” is right about what's behind his door, but all I've ever seen when someone opens Door A is a dark room beyond.

Your choice. What door do you go through?

Twenty-six pages of responses and exchanges from a variety of people follow.

 

   I also found the fable I struggled to recall.  It is a fable written by Frank R. Stockton in 1882, called, "The Lady, or the Tiger?"  Maybe you remember it.

 

[It’s] about a man sentenced to an unusual punishment for having  romanced a king's beloved daughter. Taken to the public arena, he is faced with two doors, behind one is a hungry tiger that will devour him. Behind the other is a beautiful lady-in-waiting, whom he will have to marry. While the crowd waits anxiously for his decision, he sees the princess, who points to the door on the right. The lover starts to open the door and ... the story ends abruptly there. Did the princess save her love by pointing to the door leading to the lady-in-waiting, or did she prefer to see her lover die rather than see him marry someone else?

   The closing line of the Gospel conveys the purpose of the story.  The message is not about focusing solely on what an amazing person Jesus was.  The message is that God created humankind to live life abundantly, and that Jesus is the doorway to that abundant life (John 10: 10).  The internet posting and fable help us to see how our significant, fundamental and critical decisions impact the quality of life for ourselves and others.  The internet posting, Doors, suggests the importance of gathering information and evaluating it against values and desired outcomes.  The fable points to the complexity we must cope with because we influence the choices others make, with consequences for both them and ourselves.  The Gospel presents Jesus as “the access door to a new world of living”[2], indeed to having life abundantly. 

   German theologian, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, was jailed and ultimately died in prison for his opposition to Adolph Hitler and the Third Reich. 

 

[He] once noted the advantage of celebrating Easter from a prison cell.  You become keenly aware, he reasoned, that the door is the only way out.  More than that: The door of a cell can be opened only from the outside.  When Jesus speaks of saving those who pass through the door, he has rescue in mind.  Those who find that door are saved not only from the pernicious activity of phony shepherds on the outside aggressively seeking their soul; they’re also saved from a potentially worse enemy on the inside—themselves[3].    

 

   When you think about it, there are many purveyors who claim to offer abundant life – power, wealth, medications, therapies, spiritualities and so on. 

 

The life of which Jesus is speaking—one that overflows at the boundaries—is a life that passes through the grace of God.  Jesus cautions those who would sneak through other passageways.  Phony grace and false security and make-believe shepherds abound, and so do misleading doorways.[4].    

 

So, choose your doorway wisely.  And, remember that your choice will also have both a subtle and overt influence on the lives of your family members, people you are in community with, and people who may be looking at your example for guidance.  To help you choose the shepherd of your souls, look at the contrast between the wicked shepherds in Ezekiel and Jesus.  The former were feeding themselves instead of their flocks, taking care of themselves when they were charged with empowering the lives of others.  The story of Jesus is the story of self-giving and self-sacrifice for the benefit of others.  Jesus gave his all that we might experience a renewed and abundant life.   

 

   In today’s reading from Acts, we have the description of an ideal Christian community.  There is devotion to the Apostles’ teaching, to the breaking of bread and prayers (Acts 2: 42).  There are “wonders and signs” (Acts 2: 43) indicating the work and presence of the Holy Spirit.  It is a community whose joy, generosity and thankful praise has earned the good will outside the community (Acts 2:43).  I remind you of this because, clearly, life-changing and life-transforming decisions are not snap decisions, and often need to be revisited.  Extroverts need time to talk things through.  Introverts need time for the mysterious internal ruminations they need before making decisions.  In different ways, both benefit from Christian communities where faith is formed, and where shepherds feed the sheep, seek the lost, bring back the strayed, bind up the injured, and strengthen the weak.  This is part of what we attempt to do here so that you can hear and recognize the voice of the Good Shepherd who leads us into green pastures.

 

AMEN.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

______



[1] Among a shepherd’s weapons were a short stocky club, and a long pointed staff to ward off predators.  See:  Synthesis: A Weekly Resource for Preaching & Worship in the Episcopal Tradition, 2005; Easter 4A, 3.

[2] Ibid.

[3] Ibid.

[4] Ibid.